Original Ok All Day Rugby Ball Shirt

15 reviews for Original Ok All Day Rugby Ball Shirt

D*
Rated 3 out of 5
My husband has worn rugby's for many years and his old ones needed replacement..so I ordered 2 different rugby's..buy different sellers. Both fit shol...More
My husband has worn rugby's for many years and his old ones needed replacement..so I ordered 2 different rugby's..buy different sellers. Both fit sholder fine, were long enough (some are made short) but the body of both were made much more narrow than his old great rugby's. He is not a big person and not overweight at all but these 'fit' his middle more than the old favorite 'real' rugby's that are old. Not bad. He still wears but it hugs his 'handles' and we don't like. The old ones collars are worn out so he needs new but these will not be ordered again. Still looking for new.
R***
Rated 5 out of 5
I got this shirt for my husband. He wanted a rugby shirt but wasn't willing to pay $60. This fabric is nice and thick like a rugby shirt should be. It...More
I got this shirt for my husband. He wanted a rugby shirt but wasn't willing to pay $60. This fabric is nice and thick like a rugby shirt should be. It washes well and looks great. We are both very happy with this shirt.
M*** S
Rated 5 out of 5
Very good quality made heavy-weight shirt. Reminds you of of other similar name brands. Stands up to launderings, comes out without color loss, or col...More
Very good quality made heavy-weight shirt. Reminds you of of other similar name brands. Stands up to launderings, comes out without color loss, or collar wrinkle. Even though its a heavy-weight shirt, its still breathable comfortable.
Does not stretch out in sleeves or shrinks. Great Job Amazon!
C************
Rated 5 out of 5
Only worn this shirt once but it was very comfortable and feels to be of quality material and put together well. It is a bit thicker and warmer than I...More
Only worn this shirt once but it was very comfortable and feels to be of quality material and put together well. It is a bit thicker and warmer than I anticipated but that is fine because I was wanting a comfortable cooler weather shirt to wear that looks nice with jeans or even khakis. The collar is most definitely off white but not to a degree that it looks dirty. I did buy a second one of these of a different color.
A***** C*******
Rated 5 out of 5
I was hesitant about buying Amazon branded clothes, but this shirt looks, feels and holds up (so far) as well as the pricier ones my husband has. He ...More
I was hesitant about buying Amazon branded clothes, but this shirt looks, feels and holds up (so far) as well as the pricier ones my husband has. He loves the color and the fit. Without looking at the label, I wouldn't know if this was an Amazon brand or a particular store brand that costs much more.
J* C******
Rated 5 out of 5
I have come to expect a level weight and comfort from rugby shirts, and this one ticks all the boxes. The sleeves are long enough for my orangutang ar...More
I have come to expect a level weight and comfort from rugby shirts, and this one ticks all the boxes. The sleeves are long enough for my orangutang arms (36") and the body is long enough to not ride up and let cold air get too close. Overall I am very pleased.
P*** R****
Rated 4 out of 5
Havent had long enough for a survey...not cold yet, not washed....
C* E****
Rated 5 out of 5
This is a really nice, substantial weight Rugby look shirt. I have some old, worn out, LLB rugby shirts that are twice this thick, but boy were they ...More
This is a really nice, substantial weight Rugby look shirt. I have some old, worn out, LLB rugby shirts that are twice this thick, but boy were they hot to wear except outside when it was cold. I won't actually be playing rugby in these and the fabric is great for indoor/outdoor use. Very nice quality, but not like wearing a bale of cotton.
C****** E******** i* t** B** C***
Rated 5 out of 5
I promise I'm a normal person writing this review, but I'm gonna gush. I do have a background in sewing and textiles. I don't like to spend a lot of m...More
I promise I'm a normal person writing this review, but I'm gonna gush. I do have a background in sewing and textiles. I don't like to spend a lot of money needlessly, so I tend to buy things on the cheap and pray for good bargains.

I couldn't believe how beautiful these shirts are. These shirts are gorgeously made, constructed so carefully, with the finest quality fabrics. They have heft, but aren't at all bulky, they're like an old-school rugby shirt. There's a back placket for the three buttons which are stitched on a substantive button stand, and the collar is stiff and thick, it's going to stand up on its own, if you like

We got two XX and two XL. As I made selections, some of them were cheaper than others, so keep punching around to get the lowest prices you can.

I can't tell you how deeply pleased we are with these shirts.
G***** i******* r*****
Rated 4 out of 5
Fits well. Fabric OK but unusual combination between body and collar.
t** f**
Rated 5 out of 5
This shirt fits nicely. I was concerned if I would like the fabric but it is a nice solid fabric as is found in nice quality rugby shirts. Seems wel...More
This shirt fits nicely. I was concerned if I would like the fabric but it is a nice solid fabric as is found in nice quality rugby shirts. Seems well made as well.
J******** L***
Rated 5 out of 5
Another “wtf amazon did this better than a department store” find. Great simple design, no loose stitching and fitment is awesome. Id expect to locate...More
Another “wtf amazon did this better than a department store” find. Great simple design, no loose stitching and fitment is awesome. Id expect to locate at GAP or old navy for triple what i paid. Did i mention quality wise it appears the same?
C****
Rated 5 out of 5
This is a traditional rugby shirt, good quality. I do wish someone would put a collar stiffner on rugby shirts but no one does....But this shirt is gr...More
This is a traditional rugby shirt, good quality. I do wish someone would put a collar stiffner on rugby shirts but no one does....But this shirt is great and a great buy. I am 6'1, 210lbs with 36" sleeves and this shirt in large + tall just makes it. The tall is good - long tail and sleeves fit, but maybe coulda gone XL. It's me thats in the middle of the sizes...but the large, after washing/drying fits as expected. I did also buy a LFR Scotland rugby shirt in XL (no talls) and the Goodthreads is better quality, but just a bit.
D*****
Rated 4 out of 5
Overall quality if 5 stars, fit is what takes it down to 4 stars. If you're between sizes, order up.For reference I'm 6' tall, 175 pounds and have a ...More
Overall quality if 5 stars, fit is what takes it down to 4 stars. If you're between sizes, order up.

For reference I'm 6' tall, 175 pounds and have a 35" sleeve length in a dress shirt. Yep, long arms.

Fit is on point for shoulders, neck, chest and shirt length. Sleeves are just a bit short after one cycle in the laundry. Washed on cold, dried on low.

Recommend this item, but advise you think about sizing up if you're someone with longer arms.
p*****
Rated 3 out of 5
Lately, I've been obsessed with rugby shirts, and I've bought more than a handful in the last couple months...a couple of Goodthreads rugby shirts as ...More
Lately, I've been obsessed with rugby shirts, and I've bought more than a handful in the last couple months...a couple of Goodthreads rugby shirts as my latest ones. To compare to a $100 Polo Ralph Lauren rugby shirt i have, the fabric of the Goodthreads shirt is almost there in quality. Very similar in texture, and weight. The real difference between the two, much to my disappointment, is in the difference between their collar construction. The Polo Ralph Lauren collar is nearly double the thickness of the Goodthreads collar, which as you can imagine, the Polo collar is more firm, something i find preferable in a rugby shirt. But considering that the Goodthreads is around 1/3 the price, its almost all the way there. Had the collar been as firm as any of my other rugby shirts, Ralph Lauren, Chaps, Brooks Brothers, etc, i'd give the product 5 stars. Right now i'll give it 3, because its that detail short of perfection. I haven't yet experienced washing the shirt, so i'll see how that goes...maybe i'll update this review if there's anything worth noting. I will say i tried it on, and the shirt does look pretty good on me. I was slightly skeptical since quality rugby shirts are often more expensive. Tbh, pretty sure the shirt will grow on me, and i'll like it even more than i do, once i live in it a little.